Negotiators at the United Nations ended their latest round of talks without an agreement on rules for autonomous weapons, the systems often called killer robots. The compromise outcome commits countries only to begin discussing what options might exist, rather than to adopting binding rules. The talks came after the International Committee of the Red Cross, which serves as the guardian of the Geneva Conventions, argued that legally binding rules needed to be drafted within a year. The U.N. secretary-general and Pope Leo both backed that call.

Under the compromise, countries will instead have two years to propose regulations. Negotiations over which regulations to adopt and how to enforce them will likely continue well past that deadline. The arrangement also leaves room for some of the regulations that are eventually adopted to remain optional.

Humanitarian organizations and some countries have pressed for urgent, legally binding rules, pointing to semi-autonomous weapons and drones as responsible for a significant number of civilian deaths in conflicts around the globe. Those conflicts include Ukraine, Gaza, and Sudan.

According to NPR, Russia, Israel, and the United States were the primary obstructions during the negotiations. Russia delayed the proceedings on the first day by objecting to the meeting's agenda. The United States then proposed a five-year window for discussing nonbinding, optional guidelines for autonomous weapons.

The gap between the Red Cross's one-year timeline for binding rules and the two-year window for proposals reflects how far apart governments remain. The question of enforcement, and whether any resulting rules would be mandatory, is left for negotiations that have yet to take place.

The deadlock leaves the technology's regulation in the hands of a process that has produced only an agreement to keep talking. For the United States, the outcome at the U.N. follows its own proposal for a five-year, nonbinding approach, a position that places Washington alongside Russia and Israel among the governments cited as obstacles to binding rules. Humanitarian groups that had urged swift action now face a two-year wait for proposals and an open-ended negotiation beyond it.

More technology news from TechManNews.