Apple's HomeView smart display falls short of dedicated speakers on audio quality and treats third-party music apps as an afterthought, according to extended testing by The Verge's Jennifer Pattison Tuohy, who followed up her review of the device with answers to reader questions about its smart speaker performance. The HomeView is Apple's first smart display. Tuohy tested it against the HomePod Mini 2 and found the tabletop version broadly comparable to the Mini, though with trade-offs.

The HomeView produces more bass and plays slightly louder than the Mini 2, but it is less clear and fills a room less effectively. The Mini 2 carries a single full-range driver and two passive radiators, while the tabletop HomeView packs two drivers into its display plus a woofer and two passive radiators in its base. Because the display sits over the speaker base and partly covers it, sound is affected relative to the Mini, and Apple added an accelerometer so the HomeView can adjust its EQ in real time as the screen tilts. The HomeView supports Spatial Audio with Dolby Atmos, which the Mini 2 does not.

The wall-mounted HomeView has only two drivers and uses computational audio Apple says is tuned specifically for on-wall placement. Tuohy found it sounded fine but noticeably thinner than the tabletop model, with essentially no bass, and said she would not recommend it for sound quality, though it suits conversations with visitors through a video doorbell. Buyers cannot pair two HomeViews for stereo or pair a HomeView with a HomePod or Mini, though HomeViews can be grouped with other AirPlay speakers; Tuohy noted that $300 spent on two Minis would deliver better sound than one HomeView.

Audio handoff works much as it does on HomePods, and the HomeView adds video handoff. In testing, handoff worked for Apple TV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pocket Casts, YouTube Music, FaceTime and phone calls, though calls sometimes dropped; YouTube and YouTube TV videos also handed off despite lacking a HomeView app, while Netflix and Amazon Prime Video played only audio unless video ran in the Safari browser. Tuohy cautioned that handoff is aggressive and will trigger when a phone is held within a few inches.

Third-party audio apps such as Spotify and Audible, along with Apple apps using the CarPlay interface like Apple News and Apple TV, are where the experience becomes messier. Apple built HomeView support on its existing CarPlay platform rather than a dedicated experience, so any CarPlay audio or video app works, but without search fields, with slower loading and laggier responses, and only when the user's phone is connected to the HomeView via their profile. Tuohy's biggest complaint as a smart speaker user is that these apps are treated like second-class citizens; Siri requests for Spotify content defaulted to the HomeView speaker rather than her paired Minis unless she named the room.

More gadget news from TechManNews.