Senate Judiciary subcommittee members used a Tuesday hearing to push for an end to forced arbitration in cases involving online harms, with Roblox as their immediate focus. Lawmakers accused the gaming platform of using its arbitration clause to avoid legal complaints from users who say they were groomed on the service as minors, including some children under 10 who accepted the terms. Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO), who chairs the subcommittee, told reporters afterward that opening the courthouse doors is the strongest enforcement tool available and that a jury is more powerful than regulators as companies find ways around rules.

Hawley and ranking member Dick Durbin (D-IL) introduced a bill that would make arbitration agreements unenforceable in disputes alleging child sexual exploitation or "child cyber injury," a category that could cover reputational harm, mental suffering or death. Sens. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), Katie Britt (R-AL) and Cory Booker (D-NJ) offered a similar measure that takes a different approach and explicitly covers data privacy violations. Myriam Gilles, a Northwestern University law professor and expert on forced arbitration, testified that she had never expected to address Congress about its use against 9-year-olds, and said companies change their conduct quickly once they are sued in public court.

Roblox is facing about 180 lawsuits in a consolidated case over its alleged failure to protect children, and it has sought to enforce its arbitration clause against users who agreed to the terms as minors. Arbitration would keep the public from seeing legal discovery of the kind that has surfaced in recent cases against Meta. Roblox denies it is dodging accountability. Global head of public policy Nicky Jackson Colaço said safety has been central to Roblox since launch, citing age checks for chat, age-based accounts with protective defaults for users under 16, and blocked images and video in chat, and said a legal position on arbitration does not measure a company's safety record.

A few blocks away, Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and Laurel Lee (R-FL) brought Paris Hilton to Capitol Hill to advocate for the Defiance Act, which would let victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes sue their creators for damages. Hilton said strangers have created more than 100,000 AI-generated explicit images and videos of her, and that over 50 million people have been victimized by sexually explicit deepfakes. She said she would return to Congress as often as needed until the bill becomes law, and Elliston Berry, an advocate, described a classmate making an explicit deepfake of her friend group from an innocent social media post when she was 14.

Congress has a little more than three weeks left in session before a new Democratic majority is sworn in January. Republicans are expected to prioritize President Donald Trump's judicial and executive branch nominees, including the FCC commissioner, and year-end bills such as the National Defense Authorization Act. Lawmakers are nonetheless holding out hope of opening courthouses to new litigation over deepfake abuse and child predation, after Congress failed to pass many prominent child safety, privacy and consumer protection bills and began addressing deepfakes through the Take It Down Act.

Litigation has become one of the more successful routes for survivors of online harm, with attorneys general and individual plaintiffs winning significant settlements and legal victories despite the broad scope of Section 230. Passage of the Defiance Act or the arbitration measures would expose tech companies and perpetrators of online harms to a new wave of legal challenges.

More technology news from TechManNews.